In Cunningham v. Cornell University, the Supreme Court ruled that plaintiffs bringing a claim under ERISA for a prohibited transaction are not required to plead the absence of a statutory exemption at the outset. The case involved allegations that Cornell’s 403(b) retirement plan paid its recordkeepers excessive fees — reportedly up to $200 per participant annually, compared to a claimed reasonable fee of $35 per participant.
Paper products manufacturing giant Kimberly-Clark, which counts Kleenex among its many brands, recently settled a class-action ERISA suit, agreeing to pay about 15% of the alleged damages. The $2.25 million cash settlement stems from litigation that began in 2021, which alleged that the company’s 401(k) and profit-sharing plan failed to uphold their fiduciary responsibilities. Plaintiffs claimed that plan administrators allowed excessive recordkeeping and administrative fees — approximately $78 per participant — despite the availability of similar services from other providers at just over one-third the price.
It can take more than 18 months to seal the deal on a retirement plan, and it often involves multiple touchpoints. To stay at the top of your mind, you need to look for opportunities to provide value at every stage of the journey. That means showing up consistently, not just with check-ins, but with actual, actionable insights. PlanFees gives advisors an easy way to lean into opportunities with a clear, customized snapshot of how your prospects’ plan fees stack up. PlanFees can help you turn a sales pitch into a dialog where you’re adding value right from the start.
Landing a new 401(k) plan client is no small feat. Advisors must navigate a long sales cycle as plan sponsors carefully vet providers. That’s one reason why minimizing churn in your advisory practice is so important and why a strong, proactive retention strategy is essential for long-term success.
Larger retirement plans often enjoy lower fees than their smaller counterparts, thanks in part to economies of scale and stronger negotiating power. But this in no way makes them immune to fee-related challenges. While big plans generally benefit from lower fees as a percentage of assets under management, this alone doesn’t guarantee an optimal fee structure. And to complicate matters, big plans can become prime targets for litigation if there is the appearance of excessive fees.
SeaWorld Parks & Entertainment Inc. recently agreed to a $1.25 million settlement in a class-action lawsuit filed by employees who alleged excessive fees and mismanagement of the company’s retirement plan. The settlement, which resolves a three-year legal battle, covers approximately 40,000 participants who were enrolled in the plan over a period of nearly 10 years, beginning in August 2015. The case highlights key fiduciary practices for plan sponsors.
Managing smaller retirement plans comes with a unique set of challenges for advisors. These plans often lack the economies of scale that larger plans benefit from, making it more difficult to compete while controlling costs. And with lower assets under management, they may also have limited access to institutional share classes. Advisors must navigate a complex landscape where fees can significantly impact both plan sponsors and participants — financially and legally.
United Surgical Partners International (USPI) is stitching up a legal wound with a costly ERISA settlement. After years of legal wrangling, the Texas-based ambulatory care company has agreed to pay $1.475 million to settle claims related to its 401(k) plan. While the outcome spares USPI the uncertainties of further litigation, the case underscores the importance of regular fee benchmarking in mitigating fiduciary risk.
Building strong, strategic partnerships with plan sponsors is one of the most effective ways to elevate your practice and build your book. By evolving from a transactional approach to a more collaborative relationship, you can enhance trust and deliver better outcomes for the plan, its participants, and the organization. Benchmarking tools, such as Prism Total Fees Benchmarking, Prism365, and RFP Express can play a pivotal role in driving this transformation.
Whether it’s a streaming subscription you forgot to cancel or a coupon you let expire before you could use it, nobody likes to find out they could’ve paid less than they did. And while a forgotten Netflix account might rack up a few extra dollars each month, excessive retirement plan fees can put participants — and the plan sponsor — in jeopardy. One recent study shows that a staggering 80% of plans are paying higher fees than they should.